Review Brexit red lines and keep EU membership open, says Prosper UK

The government should review the red lines drawn in 2017 on the single market, the customs union and free movement, and treat EU membership as a long-term option, according to a report published today by the centre-right group Prosper UK.

The report, The UK and the EU: The choices ahead, is released ten years on from the EU referendum and the day before the second UK-EU summit, which takes place in Brussels tomorrow. It makes 15 recommendations and says leaving the EU has cost the UK between 4 and 8 per cent of GDP.

Written by Denzil Davidson and Simon Saunders, the 83-page report argues that any future agreement with the EU should be judged against two tests: whether it makes the UK more prosperous by reducing barriers to trade, and whether it makes the country safer and better able to defend itself.

The report draws on a range of studies for its estimate of the economic cost of leaving, including work by the National Bureau of Economic Research, Goldman Sachs and the Office for Budget Responsibility, which assumes the Trade and Cooperation Agreement will reduce long-run productivity by 4 per cent relative to remaining in the EU. A separate study using Bank of England company data, published in June, put the hit at about 6 per cent over ten years.

The trade agreements the UK has signed since leaving are worth fractions of a percentage point of GDP, the report says. It cites government impact assessments putting the long-run gain at 0.08 per cent of GDP for the Australia deal and 0.13 per cent, or £4.8bn a year by 2040, for the agreement with India concluded in 2025.

The EU accounted for 41.1 per cent of UK exports in the 12 months to June 2026 and 45.2 per cent of total UK trade in 2025, according to the Department for Business and Trade’s trade and investment core statistics book cited in the report.

The report says the barriers fall hardest on smaller firms. Citing HM Revenue and Customs data, it says 39,000 small and medium-sized businesses that exported only to the EU in 2018 had stopped doing so by 2024, most often citing the volume of paperwork.

It also cites business surveys. In 2025, 16 per cent of exporters surveyed by the British Chambers of Commerce said the Trade and Cooperation Agreement was helping them grow EU sales, while 54 per cent said it was not, up from 41 per cent a year earlier. The BCC estimates customs declarations have cost exporters an extra £1.8bn since 2022.

In May, 34 per cent of small businesses trading with the EU told the Federation of Small Businesses they expected to reduce or stop that trade if the rules did not change, while 6 per cent expected to grow it. By April, 52 per cent of directors surveyed by the Institute of Directors wanted the EU to be the government’s top trading priority, up from 35 per cent a year earlier.

The report describes the case of the Cheshire Cheese Company, which it says lost a fifth of its orders in January 2021 when each consignment to EU customers began to need a £180 certificate, and said it would move a planned £1m distribution centre and 20 jobs from Macclesfield to France.

The report acknowledges that the freedom to diverge has brought some gains, citing gene editing, insurers’ capital rules, artificial intelligence and accession to the CPTPP trade partnership, but describes them as small.

Prosper UK says any fundamental change is unlikely before 2030, so the immediate priority is to complete the reset agreed in May 2025, known as the Common Understanding. It estimates that implementing it in full would recover at most 0.5 per cent of GDP.

The report says the first summit showed the cost of conceding too early. The government agreed in May 2025 to extend EU access to UK fishing waters for 12 years, to June 2038, in return for the promise of a sanitary and phytosanitary (SPS) agreement on food standards. The fishing extension was legally binding within a month, the report says, but the SPS agreement had still not been signed 18 months later.

A 200-page draft SPS text was sent to EU ambassadors on 4 November, according to the report. The government says the draft food deal will eventually bring £5.1bn a year in benefits.

At tomorrow’s summit, the report says ministers should press for the food standards and emissions trading agreements to be signed, the terms of a youth experience scheme to be settled and a timetable to be set for electricity trading. It says the government should be prepared to negotiate the contribution to EU cohesion funds that Brussels is seeking, provided it is proportionate to market access.

Beyond the reset, it recommends mutual recognition of professional qualifications and of conformity assessment bodies, under which a product tested once could be sold in both markets, a VAT cooperation agreement, membership of the Pan-Euro-Mediterranean Convention on rules of origin and treatment as a trusted partner under the EU’s “Made in Europe” rules.

The report notes that a UK business using the EU’s import one-stop shop for VAT on parcels worth up to €150 must appoint an intermediary established in the EU, while Norwegian businesses do not.

The options and the trade-offs

The report sets out a range of options, each bringing a larger economic gain in return for following more EU rules and paying more. It puts the net gain from a customs union on its own at about 0.5 per cent of GDP, a Swiss-style arrangement at 1 to 2 per cent on rough estimates and joining the European Economic Area at perhaps 3 to 3.5 per cent. It says EU membership would recover most but not all of what leaving has cost.

It recommends against treating a customs union alone or EEA membership as necessary steps, saying neither appears to offer an attractive enough balance of gain and obligation, and calls for the government to explore whether a Swiss-style relationship, with free movement subject to a negotiated safeguard, could offer a better balance.

The report says any economically substantial improvement in the terms of the relationship requires accepting free movement of people. It notes that the UK never introduced the registration requirements member states can apply to EU citizens, and would be free to do so.

On rejoining, it says there is no special procedure for a former member state, that the UK would be unlikely in the extreme to get its old terms back, and that membership negotiations would be most unlikely to start before 2030.

The report also records conditions attached to closer alignment. The National Farmers’ Union backs the SPS agreement but wants exceptions from dynamic alignment, including for gene editing. An analysis for CropLife UK found that switching at once to EU decisions on crop protection products could cut farm income by £500m to £810m in the first year. Three in four directors surveyed by the IoD said it matters that the UK keeps the power to shape its own regulation.

In his foreword, Sir David Lidington, former Minister for the Cabinet Office, writes: “It is a fantasy to imagine that we will end up with a deal in which Britain gets all the things that it wants from the relationship, while rejecting everything that the EU wants but we would prefer not to have.”

Security and domestic measures

On security, the report recommends the UK seek access to the EU’s Eurodac asylum fingerprint database, the Schengen Information System and the European Criminal Records Information System, remain in the European Convention on Human Rights and reopen talks on joining SAFE, the EU’s €150bn defence loan scheme. It also proposes a European Defence Treaty anchored in NATO.

It says UK talks on SAFE broke down in November 2025 over the size of the UK’s payment, and that joining would let British companies win a larger share of the contracts.

Two recommendations lie entirely with the UK. The report calls for the Single Trade Window, a digital gateway through which traders would submit customs and border data once, to be restarted. It says the programme was paused in November 2024 after £111m had been spent, against government-estimated benefits of £2.48bn. It also calls for the House of Commons to establish a European Affairs Committee.

The report cites YouGov polling from September showing 73 per cent of voters support a closer relationship with the EU, including 71 per cent of Conservative voters and 64 per cent of those who voted Leave in 2016.

Read the full article →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous post KPMG says AI auditors nearly as good as humans in FTSE 250 pilot