Milburn youth jobs plan would save government only £200m a year

Alan Milburn’s plan to get more young people into work would save the government only £200m a year, according to figures in his long-awaited report on youth unemployment, published today, as the cost of new job support absorbs almost all of the proposed cuts to benefits.

The former health secretary is urging ministers to cut disability and sickness payments for under-25s and invest the money in back-to-work schemes. His report says the benefit cuts would save £3.6bn by 2036-37, with a further £2.4bn generated by higher tax receipts. Almost all of that would be swallowed by the £5.8bn cost of the new system, Milburn said.

Milburn and the prime minister, Andy Burnham, have said the year-long review was not motivated by cuts. “The system I propose will spend less on compensating for economic inactivity, more on creating routes out of it; less on the consequences of failure and more on avoiding it,” Milburn said in the report.

He told Labour MPs at a meeting last night: “The Tories will say it’s too expensive, you can cut faster. But you can’t, or you’d drive young people into destitution with poor housing and ill health.”

The report sets out how to reduce the number of young people not in education, employment or training (Neet), following Milburn’s interim report, published by the Department for Work and Pensions in May.

Under the plan, the government would spend nearly £2bn a year on a new youth opportunity service to give every young person a guaranteed route into education, training or work. Just over £2bn would go on vocational courses and apprenticeships, and £1bn on direct payments and tax breaks for companies that hire young people.

It would be funded largely by replacing disability and sickness benefits for young people with a single youth allowance, set considerably below what some can currently claim.

People aged 18 to 24 would no longer be able to claim personal independence payments. These would be replaced by a new allowance available only to those whose conditions are “well established, significant and ongoing”.

Milburn began his review last year amid concern in government over rising Neet numbers, which reached 1m earlier this year, equating to 13 per cent of young people, a higher rate than in any European country except Romania. The latest official figures from the Office for National Statistics put the number at 981,000 in April to June.

“Our country is at a fork in the road. Go on as we are and see the Neet crisis grow. Or change course and make the difficult changes that can shift the trajectory,” he writes in the report.

He says the proposals should not be cherrypicked by ministers.

The review has been publicly backed by the governments of Burnham and his predecessor, Keir Starmer. Milburn was accompanied at last night’s meeting by the work and pensions secretary, Pat McFadden. McFadden and Burnham were due to address the parliamentary party about the plans again this morning.

Ministers are hoping to avoid a repeat of last year’s welfare rebellion, when Labour MPs forced Starmer to drop his plan to cut benefits by about £5bn a year. Several of the MPs behind that rebellion now hold government jobs, including Louise Haigh, the de facto deputy prime minister, and the chief whip, Anneliese Midgley.

Andreas Adamides, chief executive of Helm and founder of its Stop the Creep campaign, said: “Britain’s founders want to help tackle the NEET crisis, but the Government cannot ask firms to hire more young people while making them more expensive and riskier to take on. Higher National Insurance and new employment rules have hit the entry-level jobs young people need most.”

He called on the government to reverse the National Insurance rise, “starting with Milburn’s call to cut it for under-25s now rather than waiting until fiscal conditions allow”. He added: “With £22bn a year already spent on young people out of work, it would be money well spent.”

The campaign, backed by more than 150 business leaders and parliamentarians, has called for the employer National Insurance rise to be reversed since June. In July a committee of MPs urged ministers to scrap employer National Insurance for under-25s.

Ben Harrison, director of the Work Foundation at Lancaster University, said: “Alan Milburn is right: Britain needs a fundamental reset to tackle the youth employment crisis. But his Review leaves Government with major decisions to make.”

Harrison said Milburn had called for an additional half a billion pounds to be committed by April 2027, but that the government should prioritise “more substantial, longer-term funding” for youth employment and health support at next year’s Spending Review.

He said just under half of Neet young people, 45.3 per cent, are disabled, and that retaining welfare support under any new system would be “critical to help them enter and sustain work”.

Harrison also pointed to a shortage of entry-level roles. “Starter job vacancies have almost halved in a decade, leaving just one suitable vacancy for every six young people not in education, employment or training in the North East and for every five in the East Midlands,” he said. He called for a Community Jobs Fund to create entry-level roles.

“While Milburn is right to call for further incentives for employers to hire young people, boosting job opportunities must not come at the expense of the security of those roles,” he said. Existing incentives include a £3,000 grant for firms hiring long-term unemployed young people.

Read the full article →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous post Keeping a Useful Electric Dirt Bike Practice Journal