George Stanley on the Call He Makes When a Finished Job Doesn’t Hold Up
In this interview, he talks about one of the harder calls a contractor has to make: what to do when a customer comes back after the job is done and says something isn’t right.
When a Customer Calls About a Problem After a Job Is Finished, What’s the First Thing You Do?
I go look at it myself. I don’t send someone else first and I don’t try to guess over the phone. A cracked surface or a low spot can mean five different things, and you can’t tell which one it is from a description. I’d rather drive out and see it with my own eyes than make a decision based on what someone tells me secondhand.
How Do You Figure Out If It’s Workmanship or Something Else?
You look at where the problem is and how it’s shaped. A crack that follows a drainage path or shows up where heavy equipment keeps parking tells you something different than a crack running straight through the middle of a driveway with no obvious cause. I also think about what the site looked like when we did the work. If I know the base was soft in one spot, or if there was something about the grading that worried me, I go back to that first.
What Goes Into the Decision to Fix Something at No Charge?
A few things. First, is it something we did or should have caught. If it is, there’s no decision to make, we fix it. The harder cases are the ones in between, where the cause isn’t clean. I ask myself what a fair person would expect here. I also think about the relationship. Someone who’s been a good customer, who paid on time and treated the crew well, that counts for something. I’m not running a courtroom. I’m running a business built on people trusting me to do right by them.
Does It Ever Cost You Money to Make the Right Call?
Yes, plenty of times. I’ve eaten the cost of a repair where I wasn’t fully convinced it was our fault, because the alternative was arguing with someone over a few hundred dollars and losing them as a customer and losing my own peace of mind in the process. I think about it as a cost of doing business the way I want to do it. Short term it stings a little. Over years, it’s part of why people call me back or send a neighbor my way.
How Do You Handle It When You and the Customer Disagree About What Went Wrong?
I try to slow it down instead of speeding it up. People get defensive fast when they feel like they’re not being heard, and so do contractors. I let them say their piece first. Then I walk the site with them and explain what I’m looking at and why, in plain language, not jargon meant to win an argument. Most disagreements soften once someone feels like you actually listened before you answered. That’s something I had to learn. Early on I was quicker to explain myself than to listen.
Does Your Crew Play a Role in Catching These Issues Early?
They do, more than people would think. A foreman who’s been on a lot of sites starts to notice things during the work itself, a spot that doesn’t compact the way it should, a drainage pattern that looks off. I want my crew comfortable flagging that to me before we move on, not after. It’s a lot cheaper and easier to fix a concern on day one of a job than to revisit it six months later after a customer has called.
What Have You Learned From These Calls Over the Years?
That patience saves money, even when it doesn’t feel like it in the moment. I used to want to resolve things fast, get to a yes or no and move on. Now I take the extra day to look at a site carefully before I decide anything. I’ve also learned that being wrong about the cause isn’t the same as being wrong to fix it. Sometimes you make the generous call simply because it’s the right one for the relationship, even if the paperwork doesn’t force your hand.
What Advice Would You Give Another Contractor Facing This Kind of Decision?
Don’t decide from your truck. Go look at it. And don’t let pride decide for you either way, don’t dig in just to avoid admitting a mistake, and don’t give away work out of guilt you don’t actually owe. Take the time to understand what actually happened, then make the call you can live with a year from now, not just the one that ends the phone call fastest.
