More Minnesota kids get exempted from required vaccinations. Here’s what’s happening.
Vaccination rates for school-aged children have declined in Minnesota and across the nation as more families seek to exempt their kids from required vaccinations. Medical professionals say those exemption counts are near the point where Minnesotans should be extremely concerned, especially when it comes to schools.
In 2024, Minnesota cases of pertussis, a highly contagious disease also known as whooping cough, hit an eight-year high. The Twin Cities last year also saw a measles outbreak as the immunization rate for the MMR — measles, mumps and rubella — vaccine continues to drop.
Without a critical mass of immunized kids, children at schools and child care operations can be more vulnerable to diseases, including measles and chickenpox, that are preventable.
Here’s a look at what’s happening.
Exemptions for nonmedical reasons
In the last decade, medical exemptions for required vaccinations have stayed relatively the same. These are exemptions that have been confirmed by a doctor.
Nonmedical exemptions — which anyone can seek on religious, moral, ethical or philosophical grounds — have been on a steady increase with a noticeable spike in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Overall, these exemptions have gone up a few percentage points with the MMR vaccines seeing the most exemptions.
Why are there more nonmedical exemptions?
When it comes to nonmedical exemptions, there are those who like to make their own decisions and those who are afraid of vaccines, said Dr. Jill Foster, professor of pediatrics at the University of Minnesota Medical School.
That second group, she said, may have many reasons for their fears, including fear of needles, safety concerns or a belief in misinformation online. Whatever the reason, it can be problematic, Foster added.
“It really is a slippery slope, once you start going to exemptions that aren’t fact-based and not evidence-based,” Foster said. “And that’s kind of what’s happened. People either just say, ‘Well, I personally don’t believe in vaccines,’ or they say, ‘I have a religious reason to not have vaccines,’ which there are no organized religions that actually are against vaccines.”
Exemption laws can vary from state to state. Forty-seven allow religious exemptions and 18 allow philosophical exemptions. Minnesota allows both. These exemptions also do not need to be renewed unless a school district requires a new vaccine.
The Minnesota Department of Health collects information exemptions and shares this data with school districts, so schools can better know how protected their students are from vaccine-preventable diseases. The exemptions themselves are handled at the district level. MDH said districts approve the vast majority of exemptions.
Building trust
Right now, exemptions are around the 3% mark and around 90% of school-aged children are vaccinated. Experts, though, say the current situation is concerning.
“It is very worrisome, because a choice not to vaccinate is not a risk-free choice,” said Tabitha Hanson, a registered nurse and consultant with the state Health Department. “So a parent might think that if they don’t vaccinate, they’re eliminating risk by not getting the vaccination. However, by not vaccinating, that’s a choice to take a different and more serious risk, and we’re seeing the results of that risk when we have outbreaks of disease.”
Hanson said it’s not always because of vaccine skepticism that people file nonmedical exemptions for. It can also be a lack of access to vaccines and a lack of convenience in scheduling appointments.
According to Hanson and other experts, building trust with medical providers is the most helpful in making families feel better about immunizations. It’s important for parents to feel safe asking questions to their medical provider without feeling judgment so they can make informed choices.
Related Articles
How drinking alcohol can affect your health
Fewer than 1 in 1,000 US adolescents receive gender-affirming medications, researchers find
Sick season is in full force. What the latest CDC figures show
Woodbury dentist loses fight to keep dental license after failed implant surgeries
Surgeon General calls for new label on drinks to warn Americans of alcohol’s cancer risk
More Minnesota kids get exempted from required vaccinations. Here’s what’s happening.
Vaccination rates for school-aged children have declined in Minnesota and across the nation as more families seek to exempt their kids from required vaccinations. Medical professionals say those exemption counts are near the point where Minnesotans should be extremely concerned, especially when it comes to schools.
In 2024, Minnesota cases of pertussis, a highly contagious disease also known as whooping cough, hit an eight-year high. The Twin Cities last year also saw a measles outbreak as the immunization rate for the MMR — measles, mumps and rubella — vaccine continues to drop.
Without a critical mass of immunized kids, children at schools and child care operations can be more vulnerable to diseases, including measles and chickenpox, that are preventable.
Here’s a look at what’s happening.
Exemptions for nonmedical reasons
In the last decade, medical exemptions for required vaccinations have stayed relatively the same. These are exemptions that have been confirmed by a doctor.
Nonmedical exemptions — which anyone can seek on religious, moral, ethical or philosophical grounds — have been on a steady increase with a noticeable spike in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Overall, these exemptions have gone up a few percentage points with the MMR vaccines seeing the most exemptions.
Why are there more nonmedical exemptions?
When it comes to nonmedical exemptions, there are those who like to make their own decisions and those who are afraid of vaccines, said Dr. Jill Foster, professor of pediatrics at the University of Minnesota Medical School.
That second group, she said, may have many reasons for their fears, including fear of needles, safety concerns or a belief in misinformation online. Whatever the reason, it can be problematic, Foster added.
“It really is a slippery slope, once you start going to exemptions that aren’t fact-based and not evidence-based,” Foster said. “And that’s kind of what’s happened. People either just say, ‘Well, I personally don’t believe in vaccines,’ or they say, ‘I have a religious reason to not have vaccines,’ which there are no organized religions that actually are against vaccines.”
Exemption laws can vary from state to state. Forty-seven allow religious exemptions and 18 allow philosophical exemptions. Minnesota allows both. These exemptions also do not need to be renewed unless a school district requires a new vaccine.
The Minnesota Department of Health collects information exemptions and shares this data with school districts, so schools can better know how protected their students are from vaccine-preventable diseases. The exemptions themselves are handled at the district level. MDH said districts approve the vast majority of exemptions.
Building trust
Right now, exemptions are around the 3% mark and around 90% of school-aged children are vaccinated. Experts, though, say the current situation is concerning.
“It is very worrisome, because a choice not to vaccinate is not a risk-free choice,” said Tabitha Hanson, a registered nurse and consultant with the state Health Department. “So a parent might think that if they don’t vaccinate, they’re eliminating risk by not getting the vaccination. However, by not vaccinating, that’s a choice to take a different and more serious risk, and we’re seeing the results of that risk when we have outbreaks of disease.”
Hanson said it’s not always because of vaccine skepticism that people file nonmedical exemptions for. It can also be a lack of access to vaccines and a lack of convenience in scheduling appointments.
According to Hanson and other experts, building trust with medical providers is the most helpful in making families feel better about immunizations. It’s important for parents to feel safe asking questions to their medical provider without feeling judgment so they can make informed choices.
Related Articles
How drinking alcohol can affect your health
Fewer than 1 in 1,000 US adolescents receive gender-affirming medications, researchers find
Sick season is in full force. What the latest CDC figures show
Woodbury dentist loses fight to keep dental license after failed implant surgeries
Surgeon General calls for new label on drinks to warn Americans of alcohol’s cancer risk
Leave a Reply
More Stories
Art Deco style is popular again, a century after its heyday
By KIM COOK A century after it was formally introduced at the 1925 International Exhibition of Modern Decorative and Industrial...
Art Deco style is popular again, a century after its heyday
By KIM COOK A century after it was formally introduced at the 1925 International Exhibition of Modern Decorative and Industrial...
Jimmy Carter federal holiday: What’s open, what’s closed Jan. 9 for National Day of Mourning
Following former President Jimmy Carter’s death on Dec. 29, President Joe Biden declared Thursday, Jan. 9 as a National Day...
Jimmy Carter federal holiday: What’s open, what’s closed Jan. 9 for National Day of Mourning
Following former President Jimmy Carter’s death on Dec. 29, President Joe Biden declared Thursday, Jan. 9 as a National Day...
NFL monitoring wild fires in Los Angeles, where Vikings are scheduled to start the playoffs Monday
LOS ANGELES — The NHL postponed the Los Angeles Kings’ home game against the Calgary Flames on Wednesday with several...
Biden is a great-grandfather
By DARLENE SUPERVILLE and COLLEEN LONG, Associated Press LOS ANGELES (AP) — President Joe Biden added a new title on...